Last updated: August 2026. Rates and conditions change. Confirm the current terms on each provider's site before choosing.
マネチャ and TariTali are the two rebate services most often compared by traders using offshore brokers. On headline rebate rates the gap in 2026 is small. The differences that actually affect you are the ones underneath: how fast money lands, what the minimum withdrawal is, and whether automated-trading support matters to you.
Side by side
| マネチャ | TariTali | |
|---|---|---|
| Rebate rates | Around 140% of the market average | Among the highest in the sector |
| Cumulative payouts | ¥20 billion | Not disclosed |
| Average payout speed | About 47 seconds | Immediate to a few hours |
| Minimum withdrawal | Depends on method | ¥1,500 |
| Withdrawal fee | Free | Free |
| Registration | Free | Free |
| EA / copy-trading support | Extensive | Limited |
Is there a real difference in rates?
Not much of one. Across the major brokers in 2026 the published rates are close enough that rate alone is a weak reason to choose. Both services are funded the same way — a share of the broker's IB commission — so neither can move far from the other for long.
That makes the secondary conditions the deciding factor. If you recycle capital quickly, payout speed is worth more than a fractional rate difference. If you run automated strategies, support and tooling matter more than either.
Which suits whom
マネチャ fits you if: you want rebates in your account in seconds rather than at the end of the month; you run EAs or copy trading and want that supported properly; you value the surrounding content and community as well as the rebate itself.
TariTali fits you if: you prefer withdrawing small amounts often — its ¥1,500 minimum is low; or you weight a long, established operating history heavily in the decision.
A note on expectations
Cashback is a cost-recovery mechanism. On typical retail volumes it recovers a meaningful slice of spread cost — not an income to live on. Treating it as cost reduction rather than earnings leads to better decisions about how much you trade.
Frequently asked questions
Which one is better overall?
Rates are close, so decide on the surrounding conditions. Payout speed and EA support point to マネチャ; frequent small withdrawals point to TariTali.
Can I use both at the same time?
Not on the same trading account — one account links to one rebate provider. You can use different providers for different brokers or different accounts.
Can I live off cashback?
Realistically, no. It reduces trading costs; it is not a substitute for income. Sizing your trading around rebate income is how traders end up trading more than their strategy justifies.
マネチャ.jp is an affiliate media site operated independently by an official partner of Money Charger. Information on this page is general information, not investment advice. Trading forex and CFDs carries a high level of risk.